US and China Present Challenges to India’s ‘Make in India’ Initiative
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ambitious ‘Make in India’ initiative is encountering significant pushback from the United States and China, the world’s two largest economies. Both nations have raised concerns that India’s subsidy policies breach international trade regulations. As India strives to solidify its position as the fifth-largest economy and aims for third place in the coming years, these challenges could impact its manufacturing ambitions.
Challenges to India’s Manufacturing Ambitions
At the heart of the dispute are India’s production-linked incentive (PLI) programs, which were introduced by the Modi administration in 2020 to bolster domestic manufacturing. This initiative spans 14 industries, including electronics, pharmaceuticals, solar equipment, and medical devices, with a substantial budget of ₹1.91 trillion (approximately $21 billion). Critics, including trading partners, argue that these incentives unfairly advantage local companies over foreign competitors. For instance, Indian firms like Waaree Energies Ltd., Adani Enterprises Ltd., and Reliance Industries Ltd. have benefited significantly from government support, which includes both production-linked incentives and various non-tariff measures.
Recently, the United States imposed preliminary tariffs of 126% on solar equipment imported from India, citing unfair government support for the Indian solar industry. This move is expected to hinder Indian manufacturers’ ability to compete in the U.S. market. Additionally, the World Trade Organization (WTO) has initiated a review of a complaint from China, which claims that India’s incentive schemes for the automotive and renewable energy sectors favor domestic products, thereby disadvantaging Chinese exporters. The WTO’s dispute settlement body formed a panel to address these concerns after initial discussions failed to resolve the issue.
India’s Defense of Its Policies
In response to the mounting criticism, Indian officials have expressed their commitment to defending the PLI schemes, asserting that they comply with WTO regulations. These initiatives are crucial for India’s goal of increasing the manufacturing sector’s contribution to its gross domestic product (GDP) to approximately 25%. Currently, manufacturing accounts for about 17% of the economy. Experts, including trade economist Biswajit Dhar, emphasize that without such schemes, revitalizing the manufacturing sector would be challenging. However, he also suggests that India should consider alternative support mechanisms, such as investing in technology and innovation.
The criticism of India’s subsidy policies comes at a sensitive time, as the country seeks to stabilize its relationships with both the United States and China. Recently, New Delhi and Washington reached an agreement to resolve prolonged trade tensions, during which India faced some of the highest tariffs imposed by the U.S. on Asian economies. Concurrently, India is working to enhance its ties with Beijing, making the current situation even more complex.
Scrutiny of U.S. and Chinese Subsidy Policies
Interestingly, both the United States and China are also under scrutiny for their own subsidy practices. In 2024, China challenged certain provisions of the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, claiming that specific subsidies favored domestically produced inputs and unfairly disadvantaged Chinese products. Meanwhile, European nations have accused China of employing extensive subsidies to accelerate the growth of its electric vehicle and solar manufacturing sectors. This ongoing scrutiny highlights the complexities of international trade and the challenges faced by countries navigating their manufacturing policies in a competitive global landscape.
Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.
