R Ashwin Raises Eyebrows Over Unusual Ranji Trophy Dismissal of Manipur Batter for ‘Hitting the Ball Twice’
An unusual dismissal occurred in the Ranji Trophy this week when Manipur’s Lamabam Ajay Singh was ruled out for “hitting the ball twice” during a match against Meghalaya. The incident unfolded as Singh defended a delivery from Aryan Bora, causing the ball to roll back towards the stumps. In a bid to prevent the ball from hitting the stumps, he used his bat to intercept it, leading to an appeal from the opposing team and ultimately his dismissal by umpire Dharmesh Bhardwaj.
Details of the Dismissal
The rare dismissal took place when Lamabam Ajay Singh attempted to stop the ball from rolling back towards the stumps after defending a delivery. Instead of using his pad to block the ball, he chose to use his bat, which prompted an immediate appeal from the Meghalaya team. An official at the venue explained that the decision was made based on Singh’s actions. “He could’ve padded it away, but he chose to stop it with his bat and was immediately given out ‘hit the ball twice’ by umpire Dharmesh Bhardwaj,” the official stated. Notably, Singh accepted the decision without contesting it, walking off the field as soon as the appeal was made.
This incident falls under Law 34 of the MCC code, which stipulates that a batter can be given out if they deliberately strike the ball a second time while it is still in play, unless the action is solely to protect the wicket. According to Clause 34.1.1, a second strike is only permissible to prevent the ball from hitting the stumps. Any action deemed intentional beyond that is considered an offense, which is what led to Singh’s dismissal.
Historical Context
Dismissals for hitting the ball twice are exceedingly rare in domestic cricket. The last recorded instance in the Ranji Trophy dates back to the 2005/06 season, involving Jammu & Kashmir captain Dhruv Mahajan. This recent occurrence has reignited discussions among cricket enthusiasts regarding the interpretation of the rules in such situations. The rarity of this type of dismissal adds to its intrigue, as players and fans alike reflect on the implications of the laws governing the game.
Ravichandran Ashwin, a prominent cricketer, shared his thoughts on the incident via social media. He humorously recounted a similar experience from gully cricket, where he too was dismissed for hitting the ball twice. Ashwin’s light-hearted take on the situation highlights the difference between informal and formal cricket rules. He noted that while Lamabam Singh was given out in a professional match, such a dismissal is often not enforced in casual play.
Reactions and Implications
The decision to rule Lamabam Ajay Singh out for hitting the ball twice has sparked debate among cricket fans and analysts. Many are discussing the nuances of the rules and how they apply in different contexts. While some argue that the umpire’s decision was justified based on the laws of cricket, others feel that the interpretation of the rules could be more lenient in certain situations.
Ashwin’s comments on the incident have resonated with many, as he pointed out that the rules governing professional cricket can sometimes differ from those in informal settings. His reflections serve as a reminder of the complexities involved in officiating and interpreting the laws of the game. Ultimately, the on-field officials made the final call, determining that Singh’s second strike was intentional rather than a protective measure. This incident serves as a reminder of the intricacies of cricket and the importance of understanding the rules that govern the sport.
Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.
