Understanding Family Trusts: Who Can Serve as Trustees and Beneficiaries for Listed Company Shares?
In recent years, Indian promoter families have been rethinking their approach to succession planning as they navigate the complexities of generational transitions and evolving family dynamics. Traditional methods, such as simple testamentary transfers, are increasingly seen as inadequate. Instead, many are turning to private family trusts as a more effective means of managing shareholdings in listed companies. This shift not only addresses estate planning but also enhances governance, wealth management, and risk mitigation, while raising important questions regarding corporate and tax regulations.
Changing Perspectives on Succession Planning
The landscape of succession planning in India is undergoing a notable transformation. Promoter families, particularly those led by first and second-generation entrepreneurs, are recognizing the limitations of conventional succession methods. As they confront the realities of longevity and complex family structures, many are opting for private family trusts to hold their shares in listed companies. This trend signifies a broader re-engineering of governance and wealth stewardship, moving beyond mere estate planning.
By transferring shares to private trusts, families aim to protect ownership from personal financial issues, reduce the likelihood of succession disputes, and ensure cohesive control over voting rights. This strategic shift allows families to create a long-term framework that can endure beyond individual family members. However, such transfers also introduce intricate questions under corporate and tax laws, particularly concerning regulations set forth by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
Understanding the SEBI Takeover Code
The SEBI (Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeovers) Regulations 2011, commonly referred to as the Takeover Code, governs changes in control within the listed company sector. According to this code, any significant alteration in shareholding—specifically, a change of 25% or more—triggers an “open offer” requirement. This open offer mandates that the acquiring party must make a public offer to purchase at least 26% of shares from existing shareholders, ensuring that public investors have a fair opportunity to participate in significant acquisitions.
While the rationale behind the open offer is to protect public shareholders, the Takeover Code does recognize certain exemptions. Transfers of shares between immediate relatives—defined as spouses, parents, siblings, or children—do not necessitate an open offer. However, this definition notably excludes daughters-in-law and sons-in-law, which raises concerns for families looking to include all members in succession planning.
Exemptions and Challenges in Private Trust Transfers
While the Takeover Code allows for exemptions from open offer requirements for transfers to immediate relatives, it does not explicitly extend this exemption to private trusts established by promoter families. Nevertheless, SEBI has the authority to grant exemptions on a case-by-case basis, and many promoters have successfully sought approval for transferring shares to family trusts over the past decade.
In 2017, SEBI issued a circular outlining the conditions under which such exemptions may be granted. Key conditions include ensuring that the trust mirrors the promoters’ holdings without altering ownership or control and that only immediate relatives or lineal descendants serve as trustees and beneficiaries. This presents a challenge for families wishing to include daughters-in-law or sons-in-law in trust structures, as their exclusion from the definition of immediate relatives complicates compliance with SEBI’s requirements.
The Path Forward for Succession Planning
To effectively navigate the evolving landscape of succession planning, it is crucial to adopt a broader perspective that encompasses both commercial and generational considerations. The primary goal of the Takeover Code is to safeguard public shareholders from adverse control changes, not to hinder genuine inter-generational transitions within promoter families. Modern Indian families often operate beyond traditional patriarchal frameworks, with daughters-in-law playing significant roles in business governance and succession planning.
Excluding daughters-in-law from the definition of immediate relatives creates unnecessary compliance hurdles. As SEBI acknowledges that family trust transfers for succession purposes do not compromise investor protection, there is a pressing need to revise the regulations. Including in-laws within the permitted succession structures, along with appropriate safeguards, could enhance the integrity of the system while facilitating smoother transitions in family-owned businesses.
Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.
Follow Us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, & LinkedIn
