New Waqf Law Sparks Controversy in India
India’s recent introduction of the Waqf Amendment Act 2025 has ignited significant debate and unrest, particularly among the Muslim community. The law, aimed at addressing long-standing disputes over waqf properties—land donated for religious and charitable purposes—has been met with fierce opposition from various Muslim leaders and political factions. Critics argue that the legislation undermines minority rights and has led to protests and legal challenges across the nation.
Understanding Waqf Properties and Their Importance
The concept of waqf is deeply rooted in Islamic tradition, involving properties donated by Muslims for community welfare, including schools, hospitals, and mosques. In India, these properties are overseen by state waqf boards, with coordination from the Central Waqf Council. However, a staggering number of waqf properties—estimated at over 872,000—are embroiled in legal disputes, with thousands more facing encroachment issues. In Delhi alone, more than 1,000 waqf properties, including significant religious sites, are locked in ownership battles, primarily between local waqf boards and the federal government.
The new law aims to streamline the management of these properties and resolve disputes that have persisted for decades. However, many stakeholders express skepticism about its effectiveness, fearing it may exacerbate existing tensions rather than alleviate them. The law’s critics highlight that the complexities surrounding waqf ownership stem from unclear land titles, inconsistent regulations, and historical neglect, which have created a fertile ground for disputes.
Legal Challenges and Community Backlash
The Waqf Amendment Act has faced immediate backlash, with protests erupting in various states. Opposition parties and community leaders argue that the law is an attempt to diminish the rights of Muslims over their properties. The Supreme Court of India is currently hearing multiple petitions challenging the law, reflecting the widespread concern over its implications for minority rights.
Among the most contentious aspects of the new legislation is the removal of the “waqf by user” provision, which allowed properties used for religious or charitable purposes to be classified as waqf, even without formal documentation. Critics warn that this change could lead to a surge in disputes, as it opens the door for new claimants to challenge the status of properties that have historically been recognized as waqf. The federal government asserts that existing waqf-by-user properties will remain protected unless their ownership is contested, but the lack of clarity surrounding formal registrations raises further concerns.
Historical Context and Ongoing Disputes
The roots of many waqf disputes can be traced back to historical events, including the partition of India in 1947, which left numerous properties in limbo. In Punjab, for instance, a significant portion of waqf properties has been encroached upon, complicating ownership claims. In Delhi, the ongoing disputes involve properties claimed by both the federal government and the waqf board, with ownership assertions dating back to the British colonial era.
Experts emphasize that the rising value of land has intensified these disputes, as community members and descendants of original donors increasingly assert claims over properties that have been neglected for years. The unchecked power of waqf boards to claim properties has also drawn criticism, with allegations of collusion with land mafias further complicating the landscape.
Future Implications and Calls for Reform
While there is a consensus that the waqf system requires reform, many fear that the new law will not address the underlying issues. The removal of the “waqf by user” provision has raised alarms about the future of countless properties, potentially leading to their reclassification and loss of status as waqf assets. Critics argue that this change could undermine the very foundation of waqf properties, which have been integral to community welfare for generations.
As the legal battles unfold and protests continue, the future of waqf properties in India remains uncertain. Stakeholders are calling for a comprehensive review of the waqf system to ensure that it serves the interests of the community while safeguarding minority rights. The outcome of these developments will likely have lasting implications for the management of waqf properties and the rights of those who rely on them for religious and charitable purposes.
Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.
