Bollywood Celebrities Take a Stand for Personality Rights in Response to Rising Deepfake Technology
In recent weeks, several prominent Bollywood figures, including actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and director Karan Johar, have taken legal action to safeguard their personality rights. These rights, which encompass the ability to control the commercial use of one’s identity, are increasingly under threat from unauthorized use in various media, including deepfake technology. As the legal landscape in India struggles to keep pace with these challenges, celebrities are advocating for stronger protections against the misuse of their images and identities.
Understanding Personality Rights
Personality rights, also known as publicity rights, grant individuals the authority to control the commercial use of their identity, which includes their name, image, voice, and unique gestures. These rights are designed to prevent unauthorized exploitation of a person’s persona for commercial gain. In India, however, there is no specific law that explicitly protects these rights. Instead, judges rely on common law principles to adjudicate cases related to personality rights. This contrasts with jurisdictions like California, where such rights are enshrined in statutory law.
The absence of a dedicated legal framework in India has led to widespread violations, particularly by small businesses that often use images of Bollywood stars without permission. In response, celebrities have approached the Delhi High Court, raising concerns about unauthorized merchandising, fake profiles, and the creation of inappropriate AI-generated content. The courts have generally upheld these rights, ordering the removal of infringing content and providing a legal basis for celebrities to protect their identities.
Historical Context and Recent Developments
The issue of personality rights in India is not new. The first notable case occurred in 2002 when singer Daler Mehndi sought legal recourse against the unauthorized production of dolls resembling him. This landmark ruling by the Delhi High Court set a precedent for future cases, emphasizing the importance of protecting a celebrity’s likeness. Since then, the number of cases has surged, particularly in light of advancements in technology that facilitate the unauthorized use of personal images.
In 2023, actor Anil Kapoor took legal action against several websites for exploiting his name and image without consent. Similarly, the Delhi High Court ruled in favor of actor Jackie Shroff, prohibiting the unauthorized use of his name and likeness. These cases highlight the ongoing struggle for celebrities to maintain control over their identities in a rapidly evolving digital landscape.
The Need for Legal Reform
Legal experts argue that India needs a codified law to better protect personality rights. Currently, these rights are linked to privacy rights under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, which complicates matters, especially regarding the heritability of these rights. Unlike in the United States, where publicity rights can be passed on to heirs, Indian courts maintain that personality rights do not survive an individual’s death.
Legal practitioners suggest that establishing a clear legal framework could help define personality rights more effectively, reducing inconsistencies in enforcement. Additionally, incorporating provisions for compensation and damages could deter unauthorized use of a celebrity’s likeness. However, some legal experts caution against codification, arguing that it may limit the courts’ interpretative flexibility, which can be beneficial in unique cases.
Challenges in the Digital Age
As technology continues to advance, the challenges surrounding personality rights are becoming more complex. The rise of generative AI and deepfake technology poses significant risks to individuals’ identities. High-profile incidents, such as actress Scarlett Johansson’s allegations against OpenAI for unauthorized use of her voice, underscore the urgent need for stronger legal protections.
Experts emphasize that while laws may struggle to keep pace with technological advancements, existing legal frameworks should be interpreted in light of modern challenges. Raising awareness about personality rights and encouraging individuals to assert these rights is crucial for effective protection. As the legal landscape evolves, the dialogue surrounding personality rights will likely intensify, reflecting the growing intersection of technology and personal identity.
Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.
Follow Us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, & LinkedIn
