Failure to Walk Your Dog: The Unexpected Legal Consequences You Might Face

In India, the legal landscape is increasingly scrutinized for its extensive criminalization of everyday activities. A recent report by the Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy highlights that citizens can face severe penalties for seemingly mundane actions, such as not walking their dog regularly or tethering an animal in public. With 370 federal laws criminalizing over 7,300 acts, the report raises concerns about the implications of such over-criminalization on daily life and business operations.

Criminalization of Everyday Actions

The report, titled “The State of the System: Understanding the Scale of Crime and Punishment in India,” reveals a staggering number of laws that impose criminal penalties for routine behaviors. For instance, individuals can be charged for tethering a goat on a public street or fixing a leaky tap without the necessary permits. Even minor infractions, such as failing to exercise a dog adequately, can lead to fines or jail time. The report emphasizes that many laws target actions that are part of daily life, creating a legal environment where citizens are at risk of criminal charges for trivial matters.

This extensive criminalization is described as a “crisis” by the think-tank, which argues that the reliance on criminal law to address everyday issues is excessive. The report notes that while some laws are rarely enforced, their existence creates opportunities for misuse and corruption. The potential for legal repercussions looms large over ordinary citizens, who may find themselves entangled in legal troubles for non-compliance with obscure regulations.

Disproportionate Penalties and Inconsistencies

The report also highlights the disproportionate nature of penalties associated with various offenses. For example, promoting infant milk substitutes can lead to three years in prison, while rioting may result in only two years of imprisonment. This inconsistency raises questions about the rationale behind the legal framework, where serious acts of violence receive lighter sentences than administrative errors.

Moreover, the report points out that crimes of varying severity often carry the same penalties, such as practicing homoeopathy without a license or jumping a red light, both punishable by a one-year sentence. This lack of differentiation in penalties contributes to a legal system that appears arbitrary and overly punitive, further complicating the relationship between citizens and the law.

Impact on Daily Life and Business

The excessive use of criminal law not only disrupts the lives of ordinary citizens but also poses significant challenges for businesses operating in India. The report indicates that the reliance on criminal penalties for non-compliance creates a burdensome regulatory environment. Businesses must navigate a complex web of laws, many of which impose criminal penalties for minor infractions. This approach is viewed as counterproductive, as it can stifle economic activity and innovation.

Experts argue that the current legal framework creates barriers to business operations, making it difficult for entrepreneurs to thrive. The report suggests that the state should reserve criminal law for serious offenses that threaten public safety and societal values, rather than applying it to everyday activities. By doing so, authorities could foster a more conducive environment for both citizens and businesses.

Calls for Legal Reform

As the report underscores the challenges posed by over-criminalization, there are calls for significant legal reform in India. Authorities have announced plans to eliminate criminal penalties from over 100 legal provisions, building on the 180 already removed in 2023. This initiative is seen as an opportunity to rethink the legal approach to everyday life, aiming to reduce fear and foster trust between citizens and the state.

The report advocates for a legal system that prioritizes essential societal values, such as public safety and social harmony, while minimizing the criminalization of routine actions. With over 34 million criminal cases pending in Indian courts and a significant backlog of cases, reforming the legal framework could alleviate pressure on the judicial system and improve the overall quality of life for citizens.

Observer Voice is the one stop site for National, International news, Sports, Editor’s Choice, Art/culture contents, Quotes and much more. We also cover historical contents. Historical contents includes World History, Indian History, and what happened today. The website also covers Entertainment across the India and World.

Follow Us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, & LinkedIn